Skip to main content
UI Coach Logo
Back to challenges
Hard

Legal Hold Preservation

Design a legal-operations flow for placing selected files and custodians under preservation without broad unnecessary collection.

Desktop web

The brief

Understand the problem

Background

A legal hold may need to preserve messages and files that would otherwise expire. Overly broad collection increases privacy and review cost, while missing a custodian or repository creates legal risk.

User context

Legal operations manager Chen is opening a hold for a contract dispute involving six employees, two shared drives, and a four-month period. One employee has already announced departure.

Product problem

The team needs precise scope, defensible preservation, custodian communication, and ongoing exception monitoring.

Objective

Create matter setup, custodian and source scoping, preservation confirmation, and hold monitoring for a legal dispute.

What to design

Define the experience

Required experience

  • Define matter purpose, date range, people, and data sources
  • Review estimated scope and access authority
  • Issue preservation and custodian notices
  • Monitor acknowledgements, source coverage, and exceptions

Screens and states

  • Hold setup
  • Scope review
  • Preservation confirmation
  • Hold monitoring

Core user flow

Follow the critical path

  1. 01

    Chen enters the dispute period and six custodians

  2. 02

    The scope review distinguishes personal drives from named shared folders

  3. 03

    She confirms preservation and sends role-appropriate notices

  4. 04

    The monitor flags the departing employee's unsynced device for follow-up

Product rules

Requirements and constraints

Requirements

  • Capture legal authority, matter owner, scope rationale, and review date
  • Estimate records and repositories before preservation
  • Separate preservation from collection for review
  • Track notices, acknowledgements, source success, and custodian changes

Constraints

  • Hold details are restricted to authorized legal roles
  • Preserved content cannot follow normal deletion
  • Scope expansion requires documented rationale and approval

Reality check

States worth considering

A custodian leaves the company
A repository is offline
A file exists in several locations
The hold is released for only part of the scope

Finish line

What to deliver

  • Four desktop screens covering scoped preservation and an at-risk source

Optional direction

Visual resources

Use these as a starting constraint if you want one. They are not part of the required solution.

Color palette
#1B1A1A
#E9C5B7
#716561
#8B8C8A
#8C848C
Font pairing
OswaldQuattrocento

Oswald & Quattrocento

Clear interface writing gives people the confidence to understand what changed and decide what to do next.

Icons
Illustrations